South-South Exchange on ICT4Ag — Indian Drones Meet African Tractor Apps
Twelve African countries, five days in India, one mission: Together with partners the ICT Working Group of the Green Innovation Centres explores digital technology for agriculture
The questions at the onset
- What about blockchain? — Is it more of a hype or actually a technology essential for food traceability?
- There are apps for smallholder farmers in Africa but could they also be pertinent in the Indian context?
- We see 4G coverage and smartphones in many households of rural India. What can African partners learn from India’s impressive e-infrastructure?
These and many more questions were the focus of the Green Innovation Centre’s South-South knowledge exchange on information and communication technologies (ICT) in the agriculture and food sector. The outcome? — Fruitful discussions, valuable new business linkages and inspiring new ideas for digital solutions for field implementation.
In the hot afternoon sun next to a tomato field in Kadur, Southern India, Samuel from the Foundation for Environmental Monitoring demonstrates to 40 curious pairs of eyes how his digital innovation works. It is an app that measures soil parameters via spectrography. First, the dry soil is treated with chemical solutions from the foundation’s kit. Then the liquid will be screened using a smartphone camera and its flashlight. The the colour schemes of soil parameters such as nitrogen, pH or potassium are detected so that a farmer can learn on the spot about his or her field’s soil composition and can make informed decisions on adding lacking nutrients.
Using the app is cheaper and quicker than conventional soil testing. Results are available right there on the farm immediately. Bourehima Coulibaly, who represents the Malian start-up Satgrie, is impressed: “This technology would be also very useful in Mali. Farmers there are facing the same difficulties: Lab results are expensive, take a lot of time and they are often flawed.”
India hosted its third South-South knowledge exchange for the Green Innovation Centres
End of January 2020, 35 participants from 12 African countries, including Burkina Faso, Ethiopia, Ghana, Ivory Coast, Kenya, Malawi, Mali, Mozambique, Nigeria, Togo, Tunisia and Zambia, benefitted from the five-day programme.
The goal of the exposure visit was to promote mutual learning amongst participants on digital solutions in the agriculture sector of the global South. Experts from the private sector, implementing partners, government officials, and GIZ staff from 12 African countries, Germany, and India actively contributed to the valuable discussions, networking and exchange of learning experiences.
“South-South knowledge exchanges like this bring together different important partners from various countries. It’s a unique opportunity to learn from each other, to build new networks and to transfer and up-scale innovative ideas and solutions between countries.”
Having enjoyed Bengaluru’s cultural and culinary highlights on the day before the official start, the programme of the five-day exchange guided participants through different phases — from the better understanding of complex theoretical concepts and important framework conditions to the practical day-to-day use of digital solutions and realities for farmers on the ground:
Different individual and group exercises on the first day helped participants to understand the ICT landscape in India and triggered reflection on the framework conditions in the African sister countries. Controversial expert talks for example by th Shekru Foundation or the Mysuru Consulting Group on artificial intelligence (AI), the internet of things (IoT), Blockchain, digital payments for famers, data ownership and sustainability of digital tools gave food for thought about the existing risks and opportunities coming along with digitalisation.
African and Indian start-ups pitching their solutions
One highlight of the week was the innovative start-up slam in a co-working space: Indian and African start-ups pitched their ICT solutions in three minutes followed by 20-minutes speed dating sessions. The pitches were clustered along the agricultural value chain — upstream, production, downstream – and both – African and Indian Start-ups – presented their technologies supporting the work of smallholder farmers and/or small and medium enterprises. The subsequent business-to-business rounds made detailed information exchange and networking possible. In a vote, the slam was won by the Ghanaian start-up TROTRO Tractor.
Day 3 and 4
How does the situation look like on the ground? What do farmers have to say about apps, algorithms and AI? Day three and four led to field visits to Kadur and Hassan. Here, implemented ICT solutions within the Green Innovation Centre India along the tomato and the potato value chain were demonstrated to the African delegation.
The start-ups that were present
|One-stop solution for inputs||Gramophone||India|
|Digital food distribution platform||AgroCenta||Ghana|
|Decision-making tool||Viamo||Burkina Faso|
|Sensors and satellite images for soil requirements||Satgrie||Mali|
|Online irrigation platform based on IoT, artificial intelligence and machine learning||Smart Soft Pro||Tunisia|
|Farmer advisory services, supply chain management, traceability, certification, monitoring and evaluation, market linkage and financial services||SourceTrace Systems||India|
|Precision irrigation system||Ezzayra||Tunisia|
|Matching quality to specifications using image analysis and AI||IntelloLabs||India|
|Software platforms for agricultural extension||Tene-AG||India|
|Customised smart irrigation solution using AI & IoT||CultYvate||India|
|Training frontlines workers, connecting farmers to markets||Digital Green||India|
|SMS platform and voice messaging to disseminate information||Esoko||Ghana|
|Smart irrigation solution||Seabex||Tunisia|
|Business process management, accounting, inventory and asset management||Karabi Software||India|
|End-to-end dairy technology solutions company||Stellapp||India|
|On-farm cold storage||Ecozen||India|
|Platform for instant quality assessment and traceability linkages||AgNext||India|
|Digital platform for tractors and other agricultural machinery services||TROTRO Tractor||India|
|Digital data collection system, web and mobile platform for publishing offers and requests for agricultural products||E-Agribusiness||Togo|
|Traceability solutions along the value chain||TraceX||India|
|End-to-end spraying solutions using drones, IoTs and Blockchain||Skycrafts Aerospace||India|
|Linking farmers to retailers for better market prices||AgroWave||India|
“I thought this was going to be one of the usual talk shops where we discuss the obvious. But the GIZ ICT Study Tour turned out to be very insightful for me. Learnt a lot from seeing how India uses technology in agriculture. Given that we have similar problems, these are lessons that could be applied, though not in their entirety. I’ve got some ideas now on where to introduce some elements of IoT in our platform.”
One example was FarmHand’s precision irrigation system “Water-Hand”. This technology — controlled via a smartphone application — delivers the right volume of water at the right time according to the crop’s lifecycle, local weather and soil conditions. Benefits for the farmers are the increase in yield, saving of water and energy and the decrease in fertiliser and labour costs.
A second innovative solution is the Smart Farming App for potato cultivation. Farmers first feed the app with information about to their specific field and then receive advice customized daily. For example on pest and disease management or irrigation incorporating weather forecasting, all in local languages.
The intelligent potato “SolAntenna” third example, invented by Solentum. It senses temperature, humidity, CO2 and GPS location in realtime. It can be placed among potatoes during the entire transportation cycle to monitor and improve the respective parameters.
Besides the presentation of practical tools, participants also had the opportunity to talk to the farmers and get insights in their day-to-day work with the new technologies. “What convinced you to use the new IT technologies?”, “What is the main communication channel between you and other farmers?” “How many women in your household own a smartphone”, “Are digital solutions an incentive for the youth to get engaged in agriculture?” These were some of the questions answered by the Indian farmers to the African delegation.
The last day in Bengaluru was used for a reflection on key learnings and takeaways of the event. The German Consul General Margit Hellwig-Bötte commended the knowledge exchange in her closing remarks, thereby highlighting that the event proved that agriculture could be a young, dynamic and modern sector, which motivated participants to bring about innovative change in their home countries.
‘’The event was good and important. It has enlightened me on some digital solutions which will help me in my work and that of my colleagues’’
Handing over of the soil testing kit from Samuel from the Indian start-up Foundation for Environmental Monitoring to the Malian entrepreneur Bourehima Coulibaly
Already during the study tour potential collaborations were explored and contacts were exchanged between participants who are eager to transfer and adapt certain solutions to their home countries’ specific contexts. Some examples:
- The “ConseilCaféCacao” from Côte d’Ivoire expressed their interest to collaborate with the Indian start-ups “IntelloLabs” and “CropIn” to tailor their solutions to the coffee and cocoa value chain.
- Tunisia decided to work on ecosystem for start-ups similar to the one they have seen in Bengaluru in order to create incentives for investors to support innovations.
- Kenya showed interest in the Ghanaian machine rental app TROTRO Tractor.
- The Indian start-up TraceX on traceability along the value chain connected to Mozambique.
- Furthermore, the GFA consulting group is in negotiation with the Indian start-up Ecozen solutions about bringing their solar pumps to Togo.
- Amongst the “B2B” linkages is also Bourehima Coulibaly from Mali. Convinced with the demonstration of FFEM Foundation’s soil testing kit he and delegation members from Ghana and Zambia purchased it directly from Samuel, planning to do soil tests for and with smallholder farmers in Mali.
Group picture with certificates at the end of the study tour
The copy has been provided by Judith Wassmann, intern, and Julia Jung, Advisor at the Green Innovation Centres in India and Christian Schulze-Koch, Advisor at the Green Innovation Centres in Germany. He is also coordinator of the ICT Working Group.
For questions on the event, you can contact Christian at email@example.com or Julia at firstname.lastname@example.org