When Extreme Uncertainty Becomes the New Normal for Food Systems

A new Strategic Foresight Report outlines four plausible futures for agriculture and food systems beyond 2030 — and what they imply for policy, investment, and international cooperation in an increasingly uncertain world
Foresight

The Added Value of This Article

Hover over to have a look!

Value add for readers

  • Strategic foresight helps to identify plausible scenarios to develop strategic responses for stakeholders in international cooperation
  • Strategic foresight is an increasingly important tool for development cooperation to navigate an uncertain and unpredictable future.
  • Strategic foresight helps to leave sectoral silos, look beyond project cycles, and move towards integrated solutions
Group work during the international workshop ⎮ Visual: © Claudia Jordan/GIZ

What the future of agriculture and food systems may look like is no longer a speculative question, but a strategic one. Against the backdrop of geopolitical tensions, climate risks, and shifting global priorities beyond 2030, strategic foresight is increasingly used to explore plausible futures and test today’s decisions against tomorrow’s uncertainty. A recent Strategic Foresight Report on the futures of agriculture and food systems developed four such scenarios to support longer-term thinking in policy and international cooperation.

GIZ presented its Strategic Foresight Report on Futures of Agriculture and Food Systems in an international workshop at GIZ Berlin Representation in January. Four possible and plausible scenarios offered glimpses into the future that allowed to develop strategic responses for stakeholders in agriculture and food systems and international cooperation.

Strategic Foresight as a tool to navigate uncertainties

“Feeding the world by 2050, reducing poverty, and protecting the environment will only be possible through strong international cooperation and forward-looking action”, Nina Theis, head of section G510 – Agricultural Systems and Agriculture Supply Chains, outlined.

“Yet what we have clearly seen: many global ambitions to end hunger and poverty are at a crossroad and extreme uncertainty has become the new normal.”

Moritz Hunger, member of the Foresight Team of the GIZ Corporate Development Unit, together with the Sector Project Agriculture, used expert input and generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) to develop four plausible futures of agriculture and food systems until 2035 among the themes and methodology arche types: Growth, Collapse, Discipline and Transformation. GIZ will pilot the foresight method in selected consultations with BMZ and support partners and colleagues in partner countries in using it.

Feeding Growth (Growth)

Automation grows rapidly while rural employment collapses. Diets are increasingly unequal and there is plenty of cheap ultra processed food, while elites adopt personalised longevity diets. The system that produces food undermines its social and ecological resources.

Fractured Futures (Collapse)

Production in major breadbasket regions has collapsed due to severe climatic tipping points. The slowdown of the Atlantic Ocean currents is irreversible. Food is weaponised in geopolitical and local conflicts. Armed groups and militias control fertile land and water. There is no agreement on the Post 2030 Agenda. The global agriculture and food system has collapsed.

Controlled Stability (Discipline)

Government-managed nutrition systems replace individual food choice. The social pressure on consumers rises, food loses its cultural component. Citizens receive digital food credits tied to emissions and health metrics.

Regenerative Transformation (Transformation)

Agroecology and biodiversity-friendly practices become global standards. Investments align with soil restoration, ecosystem repair, and healthy diets. Data has become a public good that fuels inclusive and decentralised innovation.

The workshop brought together policymakers, development practitioners, researchers, the private sector, and civil society. Among the participants were international partners of the Partners for Change (P4C) network, the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations (FAO), and the Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ).

“Even with many open questions about the future of multilateralism, I am convinced that it is worth investing our energy in a post-SDG agenda that places agriculture and food systems at its core,” said Jochen Renger, Director of GIZ’s Sectoral Department (FMB) for Climate Change, Rural Development and Infrastructure.

Transformation is the most desired but also the most ambitious scenario

Surprisingly, many workshop participants discovered that elements of all four scenarios are already a reality. To make the transformation scenario come true, stakeholders need to be open-minded and share a common optimistic view, participants agreed.

“All four scenarios relate, in different ways, to a post-SDG agenda”, said Jochen Renger, on the closing panel. “The choices we make now can steer us toward very different futures.”

He added that strategic foresight helped break down silos and move toward integrated solutions. It was an increasingly important tool for development cooperation, as the recently issued BMZ reform plan “Shaping the future together globally“ stated.

Crises and shocks as levers for positive change

However, crises and shocks can also have a positive impact on future agriculture and food systems, as Permanent Secretary of the Zambian Ministry of Agriculture, John A. Mulongoti stressed in the closing panel discussion. Disruptive events like the severe drought in Zambia in 2024 had brought positive change and learning. The support to farmers who are affected has also become more targeted by means of new technologies.

Furthermore, after Russia’s war against Ukraine had disrupted wheat and fertiliser supply chains, Zambia adapted its agri-food strategies and has turned out to be stronger after the crisis: Nowadays, Zambia is not as dependent on foreign suppliers as it was before, and is furthermore exporting fertiliser and maize to its neighbours and the region.

Contact

Please reach out to the GIZ team should you like to receive the scenarios for strategic workshops with your team or organisation.

Contact

Barbara Lang, Senior Planning Officer, barbara.lang@giz.de

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!